Harold B. Rice Coins & Stamps in Buffalo (Kenmore): What to Confirm Before You Sell Coins or Bullion

Harold B. Rice Coins & Stamps is a coin and collectibles business in Kenmore, Buffalo, with the official website positioning it as a long-running local option for numismatic needs. For sellers, the fastest way to reduce uncertainty is to confirm the evaluation workflow and offer logic before bringing a collection inside.

The most useful place to start is the shop’s published contact details: 993 Kenmore Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217 and +1 716-873-8201. Those specifics matter because they anchor every follow-up question, from what categories are accepted to whether staff can review your items at the time of your visit.

Published hours: plan the visit around the time window

On the official site, hours are listed as Mon–Fri 10:00am–5:00pm and Saturday 10:00am–2:00pm. If you’re bringing a mixed collection or a larger quantity, calling ahead can help confirm whether the staff can review and discuss everything in a single visit, especially during the shorter Saturday window.

What they handle: coins, stamps, currency, and bullion

The official site navigation includes Coins, Stamps, Currency, Bullion, and Supplies. That category list is a helpful indicator of what the shop may consider, but it should still be verified for your specific items.

When you call, confirm whether the business evaluates items by:

• Category (bullion versus coins versus other collectible types)
• Condition and any acceptance thresholds
• Quantity (counted lots versus single-piece review)

Offer fairness: ask how appraisals are structured

The official website describes a reputation for “fair and accurate appraisals” and notes a history serving the Kenmore/Buffalo area since 1945. That language can be a starting trust signal, but a seller still benefits from a concrete explanation of pricing mechanics.

To get a usable offer, ask for a brief description of what drives the number for your items—such as what information is used to price bullion, and how wear or identification affects coin offers. If the shop provides multiple offer levels (for example, different conditions or packaging), request that breakdown.

Bring items in a way that speeds verification

Even when a shop works across categories, verification depends on how items arrive. Preparing your collection clearly can make the review more efficient and can help you avoid misunderstandings when comparing offers later.

Before you visit, consider sorting:

• Coins and bullion separately
• By type and condition
• Into countable groups you can reference during the conversation

If you have any supporting paperwork, labels, or original packaging, bring it as well. It gives the staff something concrete to reference when they check authenticity and condition.

Two questions that prevent the most common mismatches

For sellers, these two questions tend to reduce confusion:

• Will everything be reviewed on-site? If not, confirm what gets held back and what turnaround expectations apply.
• How is the final number calculated? Request the practical method so you understand whether offers are based on individual items, assessed lots, or blended categories.

Make the call first, then bring a clean inventory

Harold B. Rice Coins & Stamps’ official Buffalo listing gives sellers a clear starting point: 993 Kenmore Ave, +1 716-873-8201, and published hours for Mon–Fri and Saturday. Use those details to confirm category acceptance and pricing logic, then arrive with a sorted, countable inventory so the appraisal conversation stays focused.

Editorial note. Honduras Collectibles is an independent directory and does not buy or sell coins, broker transactions, certify dealers, or promise quotes. Prices and percentages quoted reflect industry-typical ranges and are indicative only; spot price is a reference point, not a dealer offer. We do not provide professional valuation or investment advice.